What if the story of Pope Pius XII as a Nazi sympathizer was actually the result of a Cold War-era communist plot to discredit the Vatican?

In a clandestine operation worthy of a spy thriller, communist forces during the Cold War sought to tarnish the Vatican’s moral authority with a disinformation campaign called Operation Seat 12.

Unearthed in 2007 by Ion Mihai Pacepa, a former Romanian secret service general who defected to the West, the plot involved fabricating a play portraying Pope Pius XII as a Nazi sympathizer.

Authorized by Nikita Khrushchev in 1960, the operation aimed to weaken the Vatican’s anti-communist influence. General Ivan Agayants, head of the KGB’s disinformation department, crafted the outline and false research for the play, “The Deputy,” while devoted Communist and producer Erwin Piscator brought it to life on stage.

Posing as priests seeking to reestablish diplomatic relations between Romania and the Holy See, spies infiltrated the Vatican archives. Despite finding no incriminating evidence against the Pope, Agayants used the stolen documents to bolster the play’s credibility. Writer and law professor Ronald Rychlak revealed that many of those involved in the play’s production and promotion had ties to communist or leftist causes.

Adding to the intrigue, declassified British intelligence from 1969 speculates that Rolf Hochhuth, the purported author of “The Deputy,” might have been an ‘intellectual agent’ working for the East Germans or Soviets. Historians Michael F. Feldkamp and Michael Burleigh support Pacepa’s account, asserting that Operation Seat 12 fits into a larger pattern of communist efforts to discredit the Catholic Church and its leaders.

In the face of covert attempts to discredit its moral authority, the resilience of the Catholic Church throughout history demonstrates the enduring power of faith and truth!

Get our inspiring content delivered to your inbox every morning - FREE!